India is contemplating the introduction of a new law aimed at ensuring that major technology companies, such as Google and Meta, fairly compensate news publishers for the use of their content on digital platforms. This initiative is inspired by similar laws in countries like Australia, which have sought to balance the relationship between digital platforms and news providers. According to a report by Mint, this proposed legislation could work alongside the already discussed Digital Competition Bill, which seeks to promote fair competition in digital markets.
The move is designed to address the growing concern among news publishers that they are not receiving adequate compensation for their work, especially given the dominant role of tech giants in distributing news content online. The proposed law would provide a legal framework for negotiations between news organizations and these platforms, helping to establish fair and transparent payment agreements.
A Push for Fair Transactions
In 2022, a parliamentary standing committee on finance, chaired by Member of Parliament Jayant Sinha, recommended that regulatory provisions be introduced to help news publishers secure equitable deals with large technology firms. However, these recommendations were not included in the Digital Competition Bill, which is led by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs and primarily focuses on maintaining fair competition in digital markets.
According to Mint, discussions are underway to explore the possibility of creating a separate law under the purview of the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting (MIB). A source quoted in the report mentioned that the MIB is considering evolving a new legal framework to ensure fair payments for news content used by tech giants. The ministry is closely examining Australia’s 2021 News Media Bargaining Code, which mandates that digital platforms like Google and Meta negotiate with news publishers over content fees, either individually or collectively.
Impact of Global Precedents
Australia’s News Media Bargaining Code has set a precedent by enabling news organizations to negotiate compensation deals with major tech platforms. As a result, more than 30 commercial agreements between digital platforms and Australian news publishers were reached within the first year of its implementation. Canadian lawmakers have also introduced legislation aimed at addressing the imbalance in their digital media news sector.
According to experts, the mere existence of such regulations compels Big Tech companies to come to the negotiating table, fearing penalties if found to be exploiting their market dominance. This has led to significant increases in revenue for news publishers in countries where these frameworks are in place. The Indian government is looking to replicate this success by introducing a similar law that will force tech giants to engage in fair negotiations with news publishers.
Addressing the Power Imbalance
The proposed law seeks to address the disparity in bargaining power between news organizations, which invest significant resources in producing quality journalism, and digital platforms that dominate the advertising market. In India, as in many other countries, news publishers are often at a disadvantage when negotiating deals with tech giants, who control the flow of digital advertising and audience engagement.
A committee headed by Jayant Sinha has also recommended increasing transparency in the way digital platforms handle data from news consumers. This includes ensuring that tech companies face restrictions on their use of this data, which is often monetized to the detriment of news publishers. The committee’s report highlights the need for proactive regulation to create a level playing field for both large digital platforms and smaller news organizations.
More Read
India’s Expanding Digital Advertising Market
The growth of digital advertising in India has further fueled the debate over fair compensation for news publishers. According to a report by Exchange4media and advertising firm Dentsu Inc., India’s advertising market was valued at Rs 93,166 crore in 2023, with digital advertising contributing Rs 40,865 crore to the total. Digital advertising saw an impressive annual growth rate of 36.6% in 2023, underscoring the growing influence of tech platforms in the advertising ecosystem.
News publishers argue that a significant portion of the advertising revenue generated by tech companies comes from their content. Yet, without proper regulations, they remain undercompensated. By introducing a new law to ensure fair transactions, India hopes to protect its news media industry from being exploited by powerful digital platforms.
A Step Toward Fairer Digital Markets
As India moves forward with its plans to create a legal framework for compensating news publishers, it joins a growing list of countries striving to establish fairer digital markets. The proposed law is still under consideration, but its implementation could provide much-needed financial relief to news organizations while encouraging transparency and fairness in the digital ecosystem.
If successful, India’s approach could reshape the dynamics between tech giants and news publishers, ensuring that the creators of news content receive their fair share of the profits in an increasingly digital world.
