The Democratic Unionist Party (DUP) has triggered the Stormont Brake mechanism for the first time in a bid to prevent an EU regulation on chemical labelling from being implemented in Northern Ireland.
The Stormont Brake is a key feature of the Windsor Framework, allowing at least 30 Members of the Legislative Assembly (MLAs) from two or more parties to refer proposed EU law changes to the UK Government. If the Government deems the Brake valid, it can veto the law’s application in Northern Ireland and enter discussions with the EU to find a resolution.
Securing support
To activate the mechanism, the DUP required additional MLAs to support their petition, which was lodged with Speaker Edwin Poots. It is understood the required 30 signatures have been secured, with backing from Ulster Unionist Party members.
DUP leader Gavin Robinson explained the move, citing concerns raised by industry representatives over the potential trade friction caused by Regulation 2024/2865, an EU law updating labelling standards for chemical products.
“This EU regulation introduces a host of new requirements for labels attached to chemical products, including new minimum font sizes and rules around spacing,” Robinson said. “This would make current labels unusable for the majority of products.”
Economic concerns
Northern Ireland’s unique post-Brexit arrangements under the Windsor Framework mean it follows many EU trade and customs rules to avoid a hard border with the Republic of Ireland. While these arrangements were intended to protect economic stability, they have drawn criticism from unionists who argue they undermine Northern Ireland’s position within the United Kingdom.
Robinson warned of the significant economic impact of the proposed regulation, noting that trade flows in chemicals between Great Britain and Northern Ireland are valued at approximately £1 billion annually.
“Applying this law under the Windsor Framework would represent a further fracture in the UK internal market, driving up costs for manufacturers and creating a chill factor for GB-based companies currently supplying the NI market,” he stated.
Political standpoint
Robinson urged cross-party support, highlighting the regulation’s potential to disrupt trade and increase costs for businesses and consumers in Northern Ireland.
“Laws made without our input, which we cannot change, and which pose a grave threat to trade flows within the UK, ought not to be foisted on communities in Northern Ireland in the absence of cross-community consent. It is right that we take a stand on this issue,” he said.
The DUP’s stance underscores its commitment to restoring Northern Ireland’s full integration within the UK’s internal market, a key objective for the party in its approach to post-Brexit governance.
Windsor framework in action
The Windsor Framework, which replaced the Northern Ireland Protocol, was designed to address issues arising from Brexit while maintaining Northern Ireland’s open border with the Republic of Ireland. It includes mechanisms like the Stormont Brake to give Northern Ireland a voice in EU law application.
More Read
This is the first time the mechanism has been tested since the framework’s implementation.
An Assembly spokesperson confirmed the notification process, stating that at least 30 Members must agree to the motion before it can proceed.
“If this happens, the Speaker will then be required to notify the Secretary of State and publish the notification,” the spokesperson said.
Government and EU response
A UK Government spokesperson confirmed that no formal notification has been received but reiterated the Government’s commitment to adhering to statutory obligations under the Windsor Framework.
The process of activating the Brake is expected to be lengthy, involving a detailed assessment by the UK Government and subsequent engagement with the EU.
The DUP’s decision marks a significant moment in the post-Brexit governance of Northern Ireland, testing the mechanisms designed to balance the region’s unique position within the UK and its adherence to certain EU rules.
The move also sets a precedent for how political parties in Northern Ireland may use the Stormont Brake to challenge future EU regulations that impact the region.
As the UK Government prepares to review the DUP’s petition, the outcome could have far-reaching implications for Northern Ireland’s governance, trade relations, and its position within the broader UK.
