ROME, 5 December (Reuters) – In a historic move, Italy has paid €800,000 (£690,000) in compensation to the heirs of a victim of a Nazi war crime, marking the first instance of direct reparations for atrocities committed during World War Two. The payment was made to the family of Metello Ricciarini, one of 244 civilians killed in a brutal massacre by German troops in Civitella in Val di Chiana, Tuscany, on 29 June 1944.
The landmark decision follows decades of legal battles and signals a significant shift in the Italian government’s approach to addressing the legacy of Nazi and Fascist crimes. It also raises hopes for other families seeking justice and reparations.
A dark chapter in history
The massacre at Civitella was a reprisal by German forces after two of their soldiers were killed in a clash with Italian partisans. The attack left the town devastated, with civilians, including women and children, executed indiscriminately. Ricciarini’s family lawyer, Roberto Alboni, who is also his nephew, described the compensation as the culmination of a two-decade struggle.
“I express my satisfaction, on behalf of my mother Metella and our relatives, who received the payment from the Economy Ministry last week,” Alboni said.
The case sheds light on the broader issue of accountability for Nazi war crimes in Italy, where justice for victims has often been delayed.
A precedent for reparations
This payment sets a legal and moral precedent, particularly for the thousands of Italian families affected by Nazi and Fascist atrocities during the war. In 1962, Germany paid Italy 40 million Deutschmarks (equivalent to over €1 billion today) to compensate for wartime damage. However, that agreement placed responsibility on the Italian government to settle claims from individuals—something it failed to do for decades.
Efforts to address this inaction began gaining traction in recent years. In 2022, then-Prime Minister Mario Draghi established a €61 million fund to cover claims from victims and their descendants, aiming to bring closure to one of the darkest periods in Italy’s history.
Senator Dario Parrini, of the opposition centre-left Democratic Party, hailed the decision as a crucial step forward. “This is an important first result in the battle to raise awareness about reparations for the heirs of victims of Nazi-Fascist crimes,” Parrini said.
The human cost
A 2016 study, funded by the German government, estimated that 22,000 Italians were direct victims of Nazi war crimes, including up to 8,000 Jews deported to death camps. Thousands of others were subjected to forced labour in Germany.
More Read
Despite these atrocities, legal and bureaucratic hurdles have historically prevented families from receiving compensation. The new reparations fund is seen as a pivotal tool in rectifying these longstanding injustices.
Moving towards justice
The compensation to Ricciarini’s family is not just a financial settlement but also an acknowledgment of the suffering endured by victims and their descendants. For many, it represents a long-overdue recognition of the horrors inflicted during the war.
Nazi troops operating in Italy often collaborated with local Fascists to carry out massacres and other war crimes. While the collaborationist role of Italian Fascists remains a sensitive subject, the government’s decision to make reparations reflects a broader effort to reckon with this painful history.
Hope for the future
The decision to compensate Ricciarini’s heirs has rekindled hope for other families seeking justice. It may also encourage further examination of Italy’s wartime past, as well as its post-war efforts to come to terms with it.
For the families of victims, the compensation is not just about money—it is about honouring the memory of their loved ones and ensuring that the horrors of the past are never forgotten.
As Italy continues to confront the legacy of World War Two, this landmark case could pave the way for broader reparations and a renewed commitment to historical accountability.
